The bill seeks to amend the lokpal and lokayukta act, 20 which provides lokpal at centre and lokayukta at states statutory backing to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain public functionaries and for related matters. They supported a new version of the lokpal bill, titled jan lokpal bill, i. Anna hazare jan lokpal bill govt government tihar jail shanti bhooshan arvind kejriwal kiran bedi jan lokpal bill vs govt lokpal bill category. Difference between lokpal and jan lokpal compare the. Jan lokpal bertujuan untuk secara efektif mencegah korupsi, mengompensasi keluhan warga, dan melindungi pelapor. This bill was submitted in 2011, and after much debate and even hunger strikes by anna hazare, the bill was eventually passed in 20, as the lokpal and lokayuktas act, 20, commonly known as the lokpal act. Whats the difference between the jan lokpal bill backed by anna hazare and arvind kejriwal of iac says, the inclusion of people in a committee drafting. What is lokpal bill india advantages and disadvantages of. Here is the goal, as stated in the preamble from the bill. Complete set of differences between jan lokpal and governments lokpal bill these differences between the two versions of the lokpal bill were claimed by india against corruption in a document released online on june 23, 2011. The lokpal and lokayuktas act, 20, commonly known as the lokpal act, is an anticorruption act of indian parliament in india which seeks to provide for the establishment of the institution of lokpal to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain important public functionaries including the prime minister, cabinet ministers, members of parliament, group a officials of the central. The jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anti corruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking. Comparison between jan lokpal bill, the government lokpal bill and the ncpri formulation subject government lokpal bill as introduced in lok sabha on 4th august 2011 jan lokpal bill version 2.
The streets are witnessing a demand that the governments lok pal bill be replaced by the jan lok pal bill jlp as drafted by the team led by. Aug 16, 2011 the jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anticorruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body that would. Aug 20, 2011 kiran bedi uploaded this difference on youtube. Difference between government and activist drafts highlights difference between jan lokpal bill and draft bill 2010 jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill draft lokpal bill 2010 lokpal will have powers to initiate suo motu action or receive complaints of. In the absence of comments from critics of jan lokpal bill, this section may therefore represent only one side of the. Jan lokpal bill the jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anticorruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body that would investigate corruption cases, complete the investigation within a year and envisages trial in the case getting over in the next one year anna hazare. The popular perception is that the jan lokpal bill will target corruption politicians.
The most basic difference between the lokpal bill and the jan lokpal bill is that the earlier has been passed by the indian government and the. The bill was reintroduced in 1971, 1977, 1985, 1989, 1996, 1998, 2001 and 2011 but was never passed. But we are still waiting for the actual bill to get passed by the government so that india. All public servants as defined in the prevention of corruption act and the jan lokpal bill will fall under the lokpal s ambit. Comparison between jan lokpal bill, the government lokpal. Essay hints on difference between lokpal bill 2010 and jan lokpal bill for school kids and senior students,200,250,500 words, for class 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11 and 12. That is the clarion call by the leaders of iapc and padma bhushan hazare.
Difference between lokpal bill and jan lokpal bill. A short film made on a few of the differences between the lokpal bill and the janlokpal bill. The lokpal is a standing machinery to investigate cases of misconduct against public men. Denouncing the antigraft jan lokpal bill drafted by arvind kejriwal government, expelled aap leader prashant bhushan has termed it a watereddown version of the original. First, there is a divergence on the jurisdiction of the lok pal. An act to provide for the establishment of a body of lokpal for the union and lokayukta for states to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain public functionaries and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Detailed information and analysis of lokpal and jan lokpal bills. Though the essence of the bill remains same, there are few major improvements have been drafted.
The jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, was a failed the first version of the lokpal bill drafted by the government of india in and arvind kejriwal on 7. Dec 18, 20 lokpal and lokayukta bill was first introduced in the fourth lok sabha in 1968. The difference between 2014 and 2015 janlokpal bills, and aaps counters the draft bill gives the janlokpal the power to investigate any allegation of corruption in the national capital territory of delhi. Aug 18, 2011 the jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, is intended as a more effective improvement to the original lokpal bill that is currently being proposed by the the government. Anna hazare adalah kekuatan yang kuat dalam mengajukan dan mengajukan ruu ini.
The first lokpal bill was introduced in 1968 and was passed by the lok sabha in 1969. Dec 02, 2015 the difference between 2014 and 2015 janlokpal bills, and aaps counters. Difference between lokpal bill and jan lokpal bill lokpal. Jan lokpal bill received both criticism as well as support from notable personalities as well as public. The lokpal bill, and the subsequent jan lokpal bill are both anti corruption bills that aimed to address the rampant corruption in india. Apr 08, 2011 the popular perception is that the jan lokpal bill will target corruption politicians. Essay about the recently passed lok pal bill end corruption. Dec 22, 2011 the lokpal and lokayuktas bill, 2011 was introduced along with a constitutional 116th amendment bill during the winter session of the 15th lok sabha on december 22, 2011. Proposed lokpal bill treats the institution only as an advisory body.
It has to be at the parliaments mercy to get access to those complaints. Apr 11, 2011 what is jan lokpal bill jan lokpal is the anti corruption bill drafted by some of the prominent citizens of india, suggesting an autonomous body just like election commission. Major advantage of this bill is all about solving the no. Essay hints on difference between lokpal bill 2010 and jan. The difference between 2014 and 2015 janlokpal bills, and aaps counters. Difference between the lokpal bill and the jan lokpal bill. Dec 18, 20 any decision of lokpal to initiate preliminary inquiry or investigation against the prime minister shall be taken only by the full bench with a 23 rd majority. Lok sabha passes lokpal and lokayukta amendment bill, 2016.
The most basic difference between the lokpal bill and the jan lokpal bill is that the earlier has been passed by the indian government and the second one is the brainchild of the team of social. Lokpal will consist of a chairperson and a maximum of eight members, of which 50 percent shall be judicial members. Aug 27, 2011 the jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anticorruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body that would. The lokpal and lokayuktas bill, 2011 provides for the establishment of a body of lokpal for the union and lokayukta for states to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain public functionaries. Before i write about my views, if you are a complete ignorant about lokpal bill or jan lokpal bill then feel free to read it from the wikipedia. Lokpal and lokayukta bill, 20 passed by the lok sabha and. Difference between aap govt and anna hazares anticorruption bill posted by. In this note, we describe the some of these differences. The point given below clarifies the difference between lokayukta and lokpal. The difference between 2014 and 2015 janlokpal bills, and aaps counters the draft bill gives the janlokpal the power to investigate any allegation of corruption in. Jul 27, 2016 the lok sabha passed the lokpal and lokayukta amendment bill, 2016 without discussion. The jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anticorruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body that would investigate corruption cases, complete the investigation within a year and envisages trial in the case getting over in the next one year. Lokpal bill vs jan lokpal bill my india maps of india. What are the differences between the lokpal and the jan.
Nov 25, 20 jan lokpal bill received both criticism as well as support from notable personalities as well as public. The lok sabha passed the lokpal and lokayukta amendment bill, 2016 without discussion. Why dillijanlokpal bill is stonger than lokpal bill. Lokpal refers to a statutory organization, formed by the government to address complaints lodged by the citizens regarding corrupted public servants, ministers and government secretaries, working at the central level, to investigate the case and conduct trials. Difference between jan lokpal bill and govt lokpal bill. All public servants as defined in the prevention of corruption act and the jan lokpal bill will fall under the lokpals ambit. Congresss delhi unit plans white paper on makholpal 02 dec, 2015, 07.
In this note i will focus on the overall objective of the bill. The jan lokpal bill was a newer version of the bill that was introduced in 2011. The bill was reintroduced in 1971, 1977, 1985, 1989, 1996, 1998, 2001 and. Lokpal refers to a statutory organization, formed by the government to address complaints lodged by the citizens regarding corrupted public servants, ministers and government secretaries, working at the central level, to investigate the case and. Public support for the jan lokpal bill draft gathered steam after anna hazare. Rather than gunning for the corrupt and corruption, governments lokpal seems to be gunning for those. Essay on the new lokpal bill 750 words article shared by the lokpal bill or also referred as the citizens ombudsman bill is an anticorruption bill that has been drafted and drawn by the civil society activists of india, seeking an independent body to investigate on the corrupted cases. The streets are witnessing a demand that the governments lok pal bill be replaced by the jan lok pal. If there is one social issue that has caught the imagination of the people of india at present, it is the issue of corruption at all levels, and the fight of the people to come up with a citizens ombudsman bill, better known as jan lokpal bill. What is jan lokpal bill jan lokpal is the anti corruption bill drafted by some of the prominent citizens of india, suggesting an autonomous body just like election commission. College project at the mit institute of design, pune.
He is not a functionary to deal with redress of citizens grievances in respect of injustice or undue hardship on account of maladministration. Mar 29, 2018 key differences between lokayukta and lokpal. Difference between jan lokpal bill and govt lokpal bill youtube. First and foremost criticism of governments lokpal bill is the clause which prevents lokpal from receiving complaints of corruption from common people.
The lokpal bill, 20, also referred to as the lokpal and lokayuktas bill, 20 seeks to provide for the establishment of the institution of lokpal to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain public functionaries and for matters connecting them. Difference between lokpal and lokayukta lokpal vs lokayukta. Lokpal and lokayuktas bill, 20, was passed in both houses of parliament. Jun 07, 2014 a short film made on a few of the differences between the lokpal bill and the janlokpal bill. Lokpal and lokayukta bill was first introduced in the fourth lok sabha in 1968. All you need to know about the lokpal bill the hindu. The jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, is intended as a more effective improvement to the original lokpal bill. An exclusive ppt on jan lokpal bill by the team of yatra a journey towards excellence slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Lokpal, oudh corridor, ashoka hotel, new delhi 110021 india.
Comparison of the lokpal bill, 2011 and the draft jan lokpal bill, 2011. The lokpal and lokayuktas bill, 2011 was introduced along with a constitutional 116th amendment bill during the winter session of the 15th lok sabha on december 22, 2011. The lokpal and lokayuktas act, 20, commonly known as the lokpal act, is an anticorruption act of indian parliament in india which seeks to provide for the establishment of the institution of lokpal to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain important public functionaries including the prime minister, cabinet ministers, members of parliament, group a officials of the. Dengan kata sederhana, jan lokpal bill tidak lebih dari versi dari ruu lokpal asli.
Any decision of lokpal to initiate preliminary inquiry or investigation against the prime minister shall be taken only by the full bench with a 23 rd majority. I will try to keep it very simple with couple of examples from my life experience. The jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, was a bill drawn up by. The jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, was a bill drawn up by some civil society activists in india seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body to investigate corruption cases. In lokpal, the selection committee consists of political members but jan lokpal consists of great personalities who do not have any linkage with political personalities such as judges, nobel awardees, bharatratna awardees, magasaysay awardees, nhrc chairperson and chief election commissioner etc. Lokpal vs jan lokpal bill if there is one social issue that has caught the imagination of the people of india at present, it is the issue of corruption at all levels, and the fight of the people to come up with a citizens ombudsman bill, better known as jan lokpal bill.
Difference between government and activist drafts highlights difference between jan lokpal bill and draft bill 2010 jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill draft lokpal bill 2010 lokpal will have powers to initiate suo motu action or receive complaints of corruption from the general public. What is the objective of the jan lokpal bill facebook. Difference between lokayukta and lokpal with comparison. The jan lokpal aimed to deter corruption, compensate citizen grievances, and protect whistleblowers. The jan lokpal bill citizens ombudsman bill is a draft anticorruption bill drawn up by prominent civil society activists seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body that would. The jan lokpal bill, also referred to as the citizens ombudsman bill, was a bill drawn up by some civil society activists in india seeking the appointment of a jan lokpal, an independent body to investigate corruption cases the jan lokpal aimed to deter corruption, compensate citizen grievances, and protect whistleblowers. They brought out their own version of the bill titled the jan lokpal bill.
663 1272 183 132 1134 769 245 1509 229 56 586 1121 531 103 557 565 1082 30 897 1380 516 894 842 950 495 114 1106 1060 528 793 1211 881 1296 120 1462 133 507 1031 851 1413 146